What is SOA?

Day before yesterday I was participating in a discussion about SOA in a meeting with architects with different technology backgrounds. These backgrounds include Oracle, Microsoft, IT Infrastructure (Windows, UNIX and Linux), IBM and SAP. Generally the discussion was about what is SOA, or what worked and did not work design, implementing a SOA. Questions were raised like does SOA fulfill promises like business agility and reuse for instance?

Well last week in San Francisco I heard Rob Daigneau say business agility is a bogus claim, because of it is not quick or easy. I agreed on this so entered this remark into the discussion with an Oracle architect, who answered he disagreed with me hence his practical experience at a customer showed it can be quick and easy. Since I do not have that much experience with SOA in practice other than one project at local government organization so to speak, I could only bring in that experience, where it did take a long time and was not easy at all. So there you go different experiences, feelings and views on the matter. There was a good point made by John Evdemon session at SOA and BPM Conference, where he made a comparison between myths and facts of SOA and one of them was that SOA’s are like snowflakes (they can hardly be compared). So thinking about this, I have to change my view a bit about business agility. It can or cannot work out given a certain situation at a company, where one tries to implement a SOA to have its promises delivered directly.

My experience lies more at start of implementation of an SOA, then a full project lasting a couple of months (or years) where a SOA is implemented completely and business agility or reuse can be noticed. Although the speaker Rob has a lot experience in the SOA field, so his argument must come from somewhere (I will ask him, email probably).

Ok back to the discussion, what is SOA? In my view SOA is where functionality from any kind of system is exposed in services, which can be composed into new services that can support a process which on its turn can be consumed. Like the model I saw at Microsoft SOA and BPM conference, where the model expose/compose/consume was explained by speakers like John Evdemon and John deVadoss. An infrastructure is needed to support the exposed and composed services, which have to be available to consumers like for instance portals, mobile device and packed apps. Besides the infrastructure it will also need procedures to help with changes to services, like versioning and maintenance. I also think that my view on the matter is not complete, because there is more to SOA than I just mentioned. Future discussion with the architects in my company Inter Access will help me to get a better view on SOA and will eventually give me a full understanding on SOA. Also one architect gave me a good reference to an SOA book I have not read yet. It is written by Dirk Krafzik e.a. and gives a more pragmatic experience on SOA than book from Thomas Erl for instance. Any comments from you blog readers are welcome to this subject.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

DTAP Strategy: Pricing and Licensing

Image
To implement BizTalk solutions it is a good practice to have an DTAP environment in place. DTAP stands for Development, Test, Acceptance and Production. Development and test environments are equal (mirrored) and same account for acceptance and production. Deploying DTAP environments is easy, because there are many factors influencing outcome of DTAP. One factor is pricing and licensing costs. BizTalk is available in different editions and since BizTalk depends on operating system and database there are some configuration options to. Here is an overview of possible configurations for DTAP environments, hence there is a nice BizTalk Feature Dependency Matrix. Besides features, there are non-functional requirements to reckon with like fail-over, availability and scalability. On Microsoft Pricing and Licensing FAQ section of BizTalk I found this on non functional side. In a large BizTalk Server 2006 R2 deployment, two key considerations ensure redundancy in all areas of the architect...
Read more

BizTalk CAT Instrumentation Framework Controller: My First Experience

Image
In past I have used log4net or System.Diagnostics.Trace component of .NET for logging and tracing. Until a few months ago the post Best Practices for Instrumenting High Performance BizTalk Solutions got my attention. I read it, but did not start using it directly as I wasn’t doing any development. These days I sometimes am involved in development of BizTalk solutions, so moment was there. Recently BizTalk CAT Instrumentation Framework Controller was released on CodePlex . The BizTalk CAT Instrumentation Framework is a high performance tracing/logging framework for BizTalk that builds upon the Event Tracing for Windows (ETW) infrastructure. It was created by Microsoft's BizTalk Customer Advisory Team (CAT). The Controller is an easy-to-use GUI for the BizTalk CAT Instrumentation Framework. My thinking was why don’t I try this UI out in combination with Microsoft AppFabric CAT Best Practices Samples . The BizTalk Instrumentation Best Practices Samples solution provides a reus...
Read more

BizTalk Server 2010 Exam : How to prepare?

Image
In previous post I yesterday I wrote that new BizTalk 2010 exam is out. And you may figure how to prepare as in preparation material nothing is mentioned.Let’s look at what skills are measured. In a nutshell these topics are: Configuring messaging architecture (setup, manage ports, configure adapters, implement messaging solutions); Developing BizTalk Artefacts (building orchestrations, create schema’s, maps and pipelines); Debugging and Exception Handling (debug orchestrations, validate and test artefacts like schema’s, maps, pipelines); Integrating Web Services and Windows Communication Foundation (WCF) Services (WCF Adapters); Implementing Extended Capabilities (this is the BAM, BRE, RFID and EDI part); Deploying, Tracking, and Supporting a BizTalk Solution (Installation in different kinds of scenario’s, deployment of applications, bindings). You can find a lot of resources that can help in preparation through BizTalk Development Center like the BizTalk tutorials for EA...
Read more